The Stories We Tell Ourselves (and How to Change Them)

How early beliefs become the lens through which we see everything, and what happens when you start to see them clearly.

Most of the beliefs we carry about ourselves were formed before we had the language to question them.

A child who wasn’t shown consistent love doesn’t conclude “my caregiver is struggling.” They conclude “I am not worthy of love.” That belief becomes the lens through which everything else gets filtered. It shapes who they choose as a partner, how they respond to conflict, how they talk to themselves at 2am.

Psychologists call these frameworks schemas. Think of them as your brain’s operating system — built early, running quietly in the background, influencing almost every decision you make. The problem isn’t that schemas exist. Your brain needs shortcuts to make sense of the world. The problem is when the shortcut is wrong, and you’ve been running it for 30 years without knowing it.

You can see it in the person who works twice as hard as everyone around them and still can’t shake the feeling that they’re not good enough. Or the one who keeps finding themselves in relationships that confirm, somehow, that they’re too much or not enough. Or the person who can’t ask for help without feeling like a burden — even when the people around them would genuinely welcome the chance to show up for them. The schema isn’t loud. It doesn’t announce itself. It just quietly shapes what feels possible.

That’s where therapy comes in

The therapeutic space isn’t about fixing you. There’s nothing to fix. It’s about creating enough distance between you and the story to ask: is this actually true? Or is this just what I learned to believe?

That process takes time. The schema didn’t form overnight and it won’t shift overnight either. But what changes quite quickly, for most people, is the moment they first see it clearly. When you can name it — when you can say “there’s that belief again” rather than just living inside it — something changes. The belief starts to loosen.

That gap — between a thought and your automatic response to it — is self-awareness. And self-awareness changes everything.

When you can see the pattern, you can choose something different. Not because the old belief disappears, but because you’re no longer fused with it. You stop being the person the story says you are, and start becoming the person you actually want to be.

This isn’t about blame

It’s worth saying clearly: understanding where these beliefs came from isn’t about assigning fault. Most of the people who shaped our early experiences were doing the best they could with what they had. The point isn’t to go back over the past. It’s to stop letting it write the future.

That’s the work. It’s not always comfortable. But most people who do it find that it changes not just how they feel about themselves, but how they show up in their relationships, their work, and their everyday life.

If this resonated with you, or you’d like to find out more about how therapy can help, I’d love to hear from you.

LP

Lindsay Perlman

MClinPsych  |  MOrgPsych  |  MAPS  |  AHPRA Registered

Lindsay is a clinical psychologist based in Sydney, Australia. She works with adults, parents, couples, and adolescents, drawing on CBT, DBT, ACT, Schema Therapy, and psychodynamic approaches. The transition to parenthood and its ongoing challenges is an area she works with regularly in her clinical practice.

This article is for general information and education only. It does not constitute psychological advice or replace professional support. If you are experiencing significant distress, please reach out to a registered psychologist or your GP. In an emergency, call 000.

← Back to the blog